However, at the Grand Lodge session in 1865, a charter was issued and the number 353 assigned to Orion Lodge.
The hall was destroyed by fired February 15, 1867, a Dispensation was issued by the M.W. Grand Master, Thomas Sparrow, authorizing the loege to meet in the hall of Evergreen Lodge, No. 222, at Conneaut. All the records of the lodge were lost in the fire, but the list of Past Masters shown is accurate.
| A.M. Brounbeck | W. M. |
| H.H. Glass | S. W. |
| P.E. Cook | J. W. |
| J.A. Porter | Treasurer |
| H.D. Keller | Secretary |
| C.W. Kendall | S. D. |
| Frank Bowlder | J. D. |
| Andrew Esterhay | S. S. |
| N.A. Walrath | J. S. |
| C.R. Smith | Tyler |
| J.D. Emerick | Chaplain |
| Moses Dickinson | 1865 |
| W.D. Scoffeld | 1866-67-68-69 |
| John R. Hatch | 1870-71-72 |
| David Y. Richmond | 1873 |
| Frank J. Lillie | 1874-75 |
| John R. Hatch | 1876-1880-81 |
| Q.A. Case | 1877-78 |
| Gaylor G. Viets | 1879-82 |
| F.E. Peck | 1883-84-85-86-87 |
| E.S. Snow | 1888 |
| Geo. E. Webster | 1889-90-91-93-97-98-1902 |
| M. Kingsley | 1892 |
| H.W. Carter | 1894-1901 |
| W.O. Merrill | 1895 |
| H.E. Hardy | 1896 |
| G.G. Viets | 1899 |
| A.T. Sill | 1900 |
| C.F. Tuttle | 1903-20 |
| F.C. Combs | 1905-06 |
| C.T. McGown | 1904 |
| Jay Craytor | 1907-08-09 |
| J.F. Fox | 1910 |
| C.M. Peck | 1911-16 |
| C.R. Smith | 1912-24 |
| C.B. Reichard | 1913 |
| R.M. Brown | 1914-15 |
| L.A. Stanton | 1917 |
| R.L. Fox | 1918 |
| W.P. Brown | 1919 |
| G.S. Thompson | 1921 |
| Harry A. Fox | 1922 |
| J.E. Davis | 1923 |
| Curtis LeRoy Fox | 1925-26 |
| W.N. Long | 1927 |
| John A. Porter | 1928 |
| Gilbert H. Meyers | 1929 |
| J.A. Pinkerton | 1930 |
| C.N. Robison | 1931 |
| H.D. Keller | 1932 |
| E.H. Johnson | 1933 |
| J.D. Emerick | 1934 |
Of those who were in service of the U.S. |
| Jesse A. Allen |
| Ralph Lewis Fox |
| Harry A. Fox |
| Raymond K. Peck |
| William H. McMahon |
| Charles D. Warner |